Previewing the December 2026 JCWE

Previewing the December 2026 JCWE

This issue of the Journal of the Civil War Era takes up a variety of questions associated with the Civil War’s impact. Our two research essays showcase new discoveries, earned through deep research, while the round-table and review essay address essential interpretive questions: When did Reconstruction end? What is the relationship between slavery and incarceration?

In the piece that won the 2025 Anthony E. Kaye Memorial Essay Award, J. Jacob Calhoun delves into coroners’ records in New Orleans and Memphis to reveal that coroners played essential roles in investigating and memorializing the consequences of white supremacist mob violence. As Calhoun demonstrates, the New Orleans coroner was uninterested in investigating deaths associated with the city’s 1866 massacre; as a result, the identities of the dead—and their numbers—remain opaque to historians. By contrast, in the same year, the Memphis coroner sought to document the dead and publicize the impact of that city’s massacre, creating a very different tone and leaving behind a more complete record. Not only does the article shed new light on political conditions in each city immediately after the Civil War; it reminds us of the value of local government records in showing how people responded to the war and emancipation.

In “The Lost Cause in the Golden State: The California UDC and the Erasure of California’s Civil War History,” Or Rappel-Kroyzer looks how the California Division of the United Daughters of the Confederacy facilitated both memory and erasure. The state’s UDC, Rappel-Kroyzer writes, is best seen as a diasporic organization whose local leaders strove to help white southern migrants make social connections in the far West while sustaining their ties to the south as a region. Grounded in deep and extensive research in membership rolls and state reports, the article also shows that California’s UDC women did not seek to commemorate California’s actual ties to the Confederacy—including the state’s pro-Confederate politicians and proslavery tendencies. Rather, they contributed to erasing that history even as they promoted markers and monuments that remembered the Confederate cause.

The roundtable, “Beyond 1877: Rethinking Postbellum Republican Party Politics and Plotting New Endpoints for the Long Reconstruction,” takes up the much discussed question of whether it makes sense to maintain that Reconstruction ended in 1877. The roundtable editor, Robert Bland, is joined by two historians and two political scientists who engage in a wide-ranging discussion of the question, touching on why so many people view 1877 as a definitive endpoint, what analytical work that endpoint does, and why we might want to view Reconstruction as a dynamic that unfolded over a longer period of time. We think specialists and non-specialists alike will find the conversation illuminating.

John Bardes’s review essay takes a sweeping look at how scholars have interpreted the relationship of slavery to incarceration. Examining the long durée of historical writing about these issues, Bardes usefully sorts the literature into categories based on founding assumptions and political projects; he points out strengths and pitfalls of interdisciplinary inquiry and takes stock of new additions to the field. Along the way, he assesses the extent to which scholars interested in the history of incarceration have viewed the Civil War as a pivot, from the longstanding narrative that convict leasing arose as a “replacement” for slavery to more recent studies that explore earlier antecedents to regimes of racialized incarceration, including slave patrols and urban policing in the free and slave states. This is a generative essay that should prompt new thinking about an important field.

This is the final issue of our 2026 volume. Over the past year we commissioned and published two special issues—one in which historians of the Civil War Era reflected on how they are meeting various crises of our own time and another in which we collaborated with historians of Brazil to bring out essays that could facilitate conversations across national historiographies. We also published research essays that connect to the subfields of the history of religion, the environment, and foreign relations; and we offered review essays that examined the historiography of Indian Removal and of historians’ uses of the concept of trauma. Our book review section provided readers helpful perspective on a range of new books on the Civil War Era, broadly defined. We love that the journal continues to be a venue for creative thinking about nineteenth-century US history, and we look forward to another year, our final one, as editors.

Kate Masur and Greg Downs

Kate Masur is an associate professor at Northwestern University, specializing in the history of the nineteenth-century United States, focusing on how Americans grappled with questions of race and equality after the abolition of slavery. Greg Downs, who studies U.S. political and cultural history in the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, is a professor of history at University of California--Davis. Together they edited an essay collection on the Civil War titled The World the Civil War Made (North Carolina, 2015), and they currently co-edit The Journal of the Civil War Era.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.