Category: Blog

Previewing the December 2026 JCWE

Previewing the December 2026 JCWE

This issue of the Journal of the Civil War Era takes up a variety of questions associated with the Civil War’s impact. Our two research essays showcase new discoveries, earned through deep research, while the round-table and review essay address essential interpretive questions: When did Reconstruction end? What is the relationship between slavery and incarceration?

In the piece that won the 2025 Anthony E. Kaye Memorial Essay Award, J. Jacob Calhoun delves into coroners’ records in New Orleans and Memphis to reveal that coroners played essential roles in investigating and memorializing the consequences of white supremacist mob violence. As Calhoun demonstrates, the New Orleans coroner was uninterested in investigating deaths associated with the city’s 1866 massacre; as a result, the identities of the dead—and their numbers—remain opaque to historians. By contrast, in the same year, the Memphis coroner sought to document the dead and publicize the impact of that city’s massacre, creating a very different tone and leaving behind a more complete record. Not only does the article shed new light on political conditions in each city immediately after the Civil War; it reminds us of the value of local government records in showing how people responded to the war and emancipation.

In “The Lost Cause in the Golden State: The California UDC and the Erasure of California’s Civil War History,” Or Rappel-Kroyzer looks how the California Division of the United Daughters of the Confederacy facilitated both memory and erasure. The state’s UDC, Rappel-Kroyzer writes, is best seen as a diasporic organization whose local leaders strove to help white southern migrants make social connections in the far West while sustaining their ties to the south as a region. Grounded in deep and extensive research in membership rolls and state reports, the article also shows that California’s UDC women did not seek to commemorate California’s actual ties to the Confederacy—including the state’s pro-Confederate politicians and proslavery tendencies. Rather, they contributed to erasing that history even as they promoted markers and monuments that remembered the Confederate cause.

The roundtable, “Beyond 1877: Rethinking Postbellum Republican Party Politics and Plotting New Endpoints for the Long Reconstruction,” takes up the much discussed question of whether it makes sense to maintain that Reconstruction ended in 1877. The roundtable editor, Robert Bland, is joined by two historians and two political scientists who engage in a wide-ranging discussion of the question, touching on why so many people view 1877 as a definitive endpoint, what analytical work that endpoint does, and why we might want to view Reconstruction as a dynamic that unfolded over a longer period of time. We think specialists and non-specialists alike will find the conversation illuminating.

John Bardes’s review essay takes a sweeping look at how scholars have interpreted the relationship of slavery to incarceration. Examining the long durée of historical writing about these issues, Bardes usefully sorts the literature into categories based on founding assumptions and political projects; he points out strengths and pitfalls of interdisciplinary inquiry and takes stock of new additions to the field. Along the way, he assesses the extent to which scholars interested in the history of incarceration have viewed the Civil War as a pivot, from the longstanding narrative that convict leasing arose as a “replacement” for slavery to more recent studies that explore earlier antecedents to regimes of racialized incarceration, including slave patrols and urban policing in the free and slave states. This is a generative essay that should prompt new thinking about an important field.

This is the final issue of our 2026 volume. Over the past year we commissioned and published two special issues—one in which historians of the Civil War Era reflected on how they are meeting various crises of our own time and another in which we collaborated with historians of Brazil to bring out essays that could facilitate conversations across national historiographies. We also published research essays that connect to the subfields of the history of religion, the environment, and foreign relations; and we offered review essays that examined the historiography of Indian Removal and of historians’ uses of the concept of trauma. Our book review section provided readers helpful perspective on a range of new books on the Civil War Era, broadly defined. We love that the journal continues to be a venue for creative thinking about nineteenth-century US history, and we look forward to another year, our final one, as editors.

Kate Masur and Greg Downs

Kate Masur is an associate professor at Northwestern University, specializing in the history of the nineteenth-century United States, focusing on how Americans grappled with questions of race and equality after the abolition of slavery. Greg Downs, who studies U.S. political and cultural history in the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, is a professor of history at University of California--Davis. Together they edited an essay collection on the Civil War titled The World the Civil War Made (North Carolina, 2015), and they currently co-edit The Journal of the Civil War Era.

William V. Turner, Multiracial Organizing, and the Unlikely Outcomes of White “Justice” after Emancipation

William V. Turner, Multiracial Organizing, and the Unlikely Outcomes of White “Justice” after Emancipation

William V. Turner envisioned a multiracial world of untold possibility in emancipation. Born enslaved in Raleigh, North Carolina in 1834 before being sold into Alabama at just eighteen years old, Turner was an incredibly well-read thinker and newspaper editor, a powerful orator, and an important labor and political organizer whose influence would stretch from Kansas to North Carolina and from the Alabama legislature to the halls of power Washington, D.C.

 

I first came across Turner’s story while completing the state level search for the in-progress “Church, School, and Community” volume of Freedom in my role as editor at the Freedmen and Southern Society Project (FSSP). I was immediately struck by the transnational and reciprocal way he understood Black freedom at the advent of emancipation. Genuine freedom would bring about untold benefits and advance civilization, not only for Black Alabamians, but also for white residents bound to the retrograde “order” of white supremacy. That vision of freedom proved to be powerful, but also dangerous, especially to white conservatives who sought to preserve Black subordination and to relegate formerly enslaved people to plantation labor after emancipation.

 

What follows is an account of Turner’s early career, the extreme dangers he faced for engaging in interracial organizing in the immediate aftermath of emancipation, and the strange case of his success in bringing at least some white Alabamians into the struggle for a more just and equal state.

 

Little is known about Turner’s life before 1865, but he emerged from enslavement as a renowned man of letters. In August 1865, he traveled to the town of Wetumpka, Alabama, having been recruited by Black families there to start a school for their children.

 

When Turner arrived in Wetumpka, he began the work of establishing connections with the white community there. “[T]he time has come,” he wrote white minister J.D. Williams, “that we the dark sons and daughters of Ethiopia has the privelege of moral mental and Intellectual improvement.” He observed that this project of partnership and Black education would be “a difficult task to start and still harder to perform. but still I hope that with perseverance and an untiring energy we may accomplish a great deal towards the mental improvement of my race.” A new school established with the support of white religious leaders, Turner argued, would accomplish just that.[1]

 

The society Turner envisioned in his letter to Williams was nothing short of revolutionary. “I hope that our efforts may be crowned with success,” he told the white minister, “so that our children may be as the rough stone passing through the hands of the artist may come out to be a shining ornament to the age in which we live.” Not Black children or white children, but our children, Turner theorized, would benefit from a Black school founded in a spirit of racial cooperation. A better world for all was within reach.

 

The impact of this new world, Turner asserted, would expand far beyond the boundaries of Wetumpka. “[W]e have now arrived at the conclusion that a brighter day is arising on Africa already we seem to see her chains dissolved, her desert plain turned into a fruitfull field her Congo and her Senegal the seats of science and religion,” he argued. African nations would be “whitend with [t]he[i]r floating commerce,” their “crowded cities sending forth the hum of business her poets and orators standing on the same shelf with Milton and Burke. and all her sons employed in the songs of salvation.” The difficult work of education in Wetumpka went far beyond racial uplift—it invoked a new, worldwide march of a multiracial civilization that would enrich the lives of everyone involved, Turner’s children as well as those of the white minister Williams.

 

William V. Turner letters

 

Turner did found a Black school in Wetumpka, the first of its kind, with help from the Freedmen’s Bureau, where Williams had apparently sent his letter. A far cry from the liberatory vision of white and Black Alabamians working in cooperation towards their mutual benefit, the school nonetheless offered new and exciting opportunities to the more than sixty students Turner taught on a monthly basis.

 

Months after his arrival and his unsuccessful efforts to win the support of white leaders in the community, however, Turner wrote the head of the Alabama Freedmen’s Bureau that “last night the police of this place made the law to suit themselves.” In his letter to General Wager Swayne, Turner explained that “several of the most respectable young Cold people of this place were cooped up in the calaboose [jail] for nothing but being out to a tea party after nine oclock also some three or four who were coming from church were treated in the same manner myself among the number.” Arrested for the grave crime of walking home from church, Turner asked Swayne “to do something in our behalf for under the men who controls the affairs of this town we will never enjoy any of the rights of freedmen in this town unless some alterations is made.” Rather than supporting Black churches and schools, as Turner had hoped, white leaders and local officials abused the law to break up these newly-formed Black institutions. Nonetheless, it does not appear that Freedmen’s Bureau Assistant Commissioner Swayne responded to Turner’s pleas or took any action in the case.[2]

 

Speaking to Black attendees of an Independence Day celebration in 1866, Turner tied the destruction of slavery to the transformation of the state, one that rested on a partnership with white Alabamians and former enslavers. Published in the July 26th issue of the Mobile Nationalist, Turner’s speech offered a vision of emancipation that transcended the present, attempting to convert a freedom in name only to one that reflected total liberation. “The days are no more when our labor, pastime, strength and health are only portions of a master’s wealth,” he observed, now that “[w]e rise to look as freemen on God’s daylight, and the curfew no longer tools our hour for retiring.” Yet that “[f]reedom will prove worse than worthless,” Turner argued, “if we fail to improve upon it.” This required incredible discipline and overwhelming virtue since “the duties which [freedom] devolves upon us is great—yes, almost overpowering.”[3]

 

Turner told listeners that Black Alabamians would have to cultivate friendship and community with their former enslavers, those most ardent enemies of freedom. “Practice politeness yourselves, and teach it to your children; and be sure to cultivate friendly feelings towards those who were your former masters—your homes are to be among them, and it is of the utmost importance that those kindly relations which have heretofore existed be not rudely broken.” Turning the language of freedom into genuine liberation could only be achieved, in Turner’s analysis, through a spirit of friendship and shared labor with those in white communities willing to engage in the struggle, the very relationship Turner had proposed to Reverend Williams a year earlier.

 

While Turner’s extensive work and public speaking on behalf of interracial organizing and the mutual benefits it would bring to both Black and white Alabamians charted a path towards multiracial democracy, it also made him a target.

 

In September 1866, just months after his soaring Independence Day speech, Turner was called out of bed “to address an assembly of col[ore]d people at the African church relative to a cold National Convention to be holden at Cincinnatti.” He rose to the occasion, but explained that he “was carefull how I spoke. using no epithets nor language disrepectful of any one.” Nonetheless, Turner recalled, “[d]uring my discourse. a Justice of the Peace, James Thomas, by name came up and using profane language threatend to arrest every one of us.” Turner replied that it would be illegal to do so and continued his speech.[4]

 

The next day, Turner encountered Thomas while crossing a bridge over the Coosa River. The justice of the peace confronted him, Turner recalled, shouting “‘you are a d—d liar,’ and struck me three times with a stick which shivered to pieces.” Then, “he drew a long murderous looking knife, with which he attempted to stab me, which I avoided by getting out of his way as fast as I could.” Turner reported the assault and attempted murder at the hands of the local official to General Swayne, noting that “[a]ll this was done in the presense of the Marshall of the town, who took no steps whatever to arrest the aforesaid Jas Thomas in his murderous intentions.” If justice was to be done, Turner suggested, it would have to come from Swayne, but again, the Assistant Commissioner apparently failed to respond.

 

Turner hired a lawyer and attempted to secure justice in the wake of the assault, writing again to General Swayne for advice and assistance. “There is more misrepresentations of my case among the white people than I ever though[t] of,” he lamented, observing that “[t]hey are greatly incensed at the idea of a negro trying to prosecute a white man.” Even as Turner sought the protections of the law, he was forced to operate in hiding. Despite the language of democracy and equality, white Alabamians refused to accept a legal system that recognized the rights of their Black neighbors. “They have been looking around every night for a chance to kill me,” he explained, “but I have avoided them thus far. It is very dangerous for me to stay here. But I will put my trust in the Lord and stay as long as I can.” Once more, it does not appear that the head of the Alabama Freedmen’s Bureau, General Swayne, took any action in response to Turner’s pleas for justice.

 

However, a letter from Reverend Williams about the case did reach the desk of the governor of Alabama, Robert M. Patton. In it, the minister explained that the current trouble in the town grew in part from “a little too frequent a use of negro right, of their privilege to hold orderly meetings.” “In regard to the negroes, some few of them are quite indiscret,” he complained, and “a few others who hear read from the ‘National’ of Mobile, the ‘Radicalism’ it contains[?] become progressives and now, and then, manifest this spirit by [hostile?] words.” This was the crucial context for the attack on Turner for Reverend Williams, when James Thomas “publicly assaulted one of the negro speakers, in a furious way, breaking his cane over him and then drawing his knife upon him—of which he plod guilty before the Citty Council and paid a fine of $10.” Guilty of reading newspapers and making speeches, the white minister suggested that Black organizers like Turner had created this problem in the first place. While Williams positioned himself as sympathetic to Turner and criticized Thomas as “rather an impetus young man,” he devoted the bulk of his comments to complaining about his Black neighbors and the narrow expressions of freedom to which they availed themselves.

 

If this had been the end of the story—of the assault on Turner and his efforts at multiracial organizing in the immediate aftermath of emancipation—it would have been understandable. White local officials like Thomas and prominent figures like Williams seemed at best unwilling to support genuine equality and, in the case of Thomas, openly hostile. But Turner could not be so easily defeated.

 

After serving a term in the Alabama State legislature representing Elmore County, Turner turned his attention to campaigning for the state Republican Party in 1869. To help build support for the campaign, Turner sought the help of none other than James Thomas. “I want you to get the signatures of the Postmaster and Esq. Helony,” he wrote the former justice of the peace who had once tried to kill him, since “[t]hey promised me that they would sign” the petition enlisting Benjamin W. Norris to run for Congress. Turner also asked Thomas to enlist “old man Ned Adkins, Isaac Parker, and other leading colored men.”

 

Turner’s letter to Thomas offers significant insight into the interracial organizing that Turner had pursued since the moment of emancipation, and which he would continue to advance as integral to multiracial democracy. The Republican Party, which had been the party of democracy and equality in the 1860s, could only be advanced through a genuinely multiracial coalition. Here, Turner put into practice the words of his Independence Day speech, attempting to organize with the man who had beaten him if it was possible to do so. And in fact, Turner not only partnered with Thomas, but assigned him to gather the endorsements of potential supporters, both Black and white.

 

Thomas, for his part, took up the work after Turner “came to me in Montgomery and told me personally to return home and go to work for Maj. Norris, saying, that every true Republican should rally at once to his support, or we are defeated, which I did.”

 

A remarkable story, it is one that might have ended very differently and illustrates the instability of the white conservative lawlessness against which Turner struggled so fiercely. Thomas might have succeeded in stabbing Turner, for example, or white locals might have found Turner in hiding and assassinated him. These tragedies unfolded constantly in the postemancipation South. They still do. But contingency cuts both ways. White Alabamians might have chosen democracy, equality, and the rule of law. They might have chosen a stable society that, as Turner had written to Reverend Williams, would have advanced their collective prosperity and civilization.

 

What Turner pursued was a vision of an assertive democracy more powerful than white supremacy. One in which the rule of law would be brought about, not only through petitions and prayer, but by capturing and totally transforming the lawless system that existed. It was a vision too compelling even for the justice of the peace to deny.

 

 

NOTE:

While we usually publish transcriptions of the documents in our collection at FSSP, I have opted not to do so here because some of this material will be published in forthcoming volumes of Freedom. I also want to thank the former editors of FSSP, who compiled and analyzed these documents over the course of the project’s history, and especially John McKerley, Steven F. Miller, and Leslie S. Rowland for editorial work on two of the documents provided here.

 

[1] William V. Turner to Rev. J. D. Williams, 16 Aug. 1865, Unregistered Letters Received, series 9, AL Assistant Commissioner, Bureau of Refugees, Freedmen, & Abandoned Lands, Record Group 105, National Archives, FSSP Project Number A-1806 (noted hereafter in brackets).

[2] William V. Turner to his honor Gen. Wager Swayne, 17 Nov. 1865, Unregistered Letters Received, series 9, AL Assistant Commissioner, Bureau of Refugees, Freedmen, & Abandoned Lands, Record Group 105, National Archives [A-1653].

[3] The text of Turner’s speech is printed in Richard Bailey, Neither Carpetbaggers Nor Scalawags: Black Officeholders during the Reconstruction of Alabama, 1867-1878 (NewSouth Books, 2010), 371-372.

[4] Statement of Wm. V. Turner, 10 Sept. 1866, and Wm. V. Turner to Maj Gen Wager Swayne, 13 Sept. [18]66, Unregistered Letters Received, series 9, AL Assistant Commissioner, Bureau of Refugees, Freedmen, & Abandoned Lands, Record Group 105, National Archives [A-1808].

William Horne

William Horne is a historian of white supremacy and Black liberation movements in the United States. His recent scholarly publications include “White Supremacy and Fraud: The ‘Abolitionist’ Work of Henry Frisbie,” Civil War History 70 no. 3, (September 2024): 69-86; “Abaline Miller and the Struggle for Justice against the Employer Police State after Slavery,” in The Civil War Era and the Summer of 2020, Andy Slap and Hilary Green, eds. (New York: Fordham University Press, 2024), 38-46; “Necessary Utopias: Black Agitation and Human Survival,” Green Theory & Praxis 16 no. 1 (February 2024): 14-33; and “Towards an Unpatriotic Education: Du Bois, Woodson, and the Threat of Nationalist Mythologies,” Journal of Academic Freedom 13 (2022): 1-16. His current book project, “Carnivals of Violence,” examines the systems of white supremacy enshrined in state institutions after emancipation. Horne was co-founder and longtime editor of The Activist History Review and has spoken and published extensively in public-facing venues including TIME, Truthout, The Nation, The Daily Beast, The Washington Post, and the Bucks County Beacon.

JCWE Special Issue Interview with Keila Grinberg and Fabiane Popinigis

JCWE Special Issue Interview with Keila Grinberg and Fabiane Popinigis

In today’s Muster, JCWE Associate Editor Robert Bland discusses the journal’s recent special issue, “Noisy Archives: Race and the Social History of the Law in Brazil,” with Keila Grinberg and Fabiane Popingis. Dr. Keila Grinberg is a Professor of Brazilian and Latin American History and Director of the Center for Latin American Studies at the University of Pittsburgh. Dr. Popinigis is an associate professor of History at Federal Rural University of Rio de Janeiro.

 

This interview has been edited for length and clarity

 

Robert Bland: I wonder if you could talk about the origins of this issue, right? How did the idea come about? What was it like working with the JCWE and the Richards Center?

 

Keila Grinberg: So, when the journal approached us, the other editor and me, the idea was to provide the readers of the Journal of the Civil War a sense of the connections with Brazilian historiography, and especially, of course, 19th-century historiography. And one of the things that we, I mean, this is sort of the obvious comparison is that there was a war in South America, the so-called Paraguayan war or Brazilian War between Brazil, Paraguay, Uruguay, and Argentina in the 1860s.

But we actually decided to do a different thing. And instead of using Brazil as a comparative case, as there is a long history of comparative studies between Brazil and the US, especially around slavery and 19th-century slavery, we decided to focus on topics that relate to race and the centrality of race to understanding Brazilian society, but not the ones that are normally used for comparison. So, we wanted to avoid, let’s say the comparative fact, right? Just thinking about Brazilian history and Brazilian society in its own terms.

 

Robert Bland: Tied to that point, I really appreciated the “noisy archives” framework that you used to introduce the journal. I wonder if you could talk a little bit about this framework, talk about how the idea of a noisy archive emerged. What archival silences do you think have been pervasive in Brazilian history? And how are you seeking to reintroduce some of those lost voices?

 

Keila Grinberg: Thank you for this question because this was a really important point for us. I mean, one is, of course, a direct engagement with a whole discussion about silence and silencing in the archives, especially when you work with slavery and other underrepresented voices from the past. But the idea of the noisy archives, I think it’s an invitation for a conversation about what the archives tell us and what the archives cannot tell us. And every historian working in an archive knows that the archive cannot tell us everything about the past.

I bet that’s history 101, and that’s impossible. And even though in the structure of the organization of the archives are, of course, voices that were not as heard or as visible in the past, when you actually look at the documents, you can hear all those voices. That’s the idea of noise. That we can, in fact, know a lot; and especially in the sort of Portuguese world the ways that the documents are structured, the ways that you can see, for instance, witnesses in trials, it’s different than the US and the Anglo-Saxon world. You can actually engage a lot with those, let’s say, voices. Even though they are not first person necessarily. So, the idea of noise is that you need to know how to hear them, but they are there.

 

Robert Bland: I’m wondering what you found particularly interesting about the new social histories of the law in slavery and abolition? How do you think about legal history, legal archives, and why are scholars of race in kind of Brazil really interested in kind of the turn towards the social history of the law?

 

Keila Grinberg: I think, and then It would be also interesting to know in a particular case about Fabiane’s work, but we’ve been working, this is a very powerful historiography that are very connected with the US. So that’s also why we wanted to frame it around the social history of the law, because, you know, in the US, in Kate Masur’s work, but also Rebecca Scott about Cuba and all the historiography that came after that it’s really an important topic of dialogue between us in Brazil and what is being done since the mid 1980s in the US. So, the idea of the social history of the law is precisely that the law is not defined by the structure. You know, even though the structures are important. When you think about the law and think about the legal struggles, and you think about the people that are interacting with the law.

The results are not predefined. I will use the World Cup metaphor. When you were watching soccer, there’s always space for the underdog, like the possibility for the goalie to do this amazing thing, of not letting the goal to come in, and just and that’s sort of thing. Of course, I’m abusing of this metaphor, but it’s this way that, at first, the law is really important to understand, not just Brazilian, Latin American society, and I would say U.S. society too. So it’s not something that is predefined by the economic structures even though, of course, it is important to understand.

And the second point is that when you are talking about. Legally, the fine categories such as race have a deep connection with reality, but those legal categories have a real impact on people’s lives. This is something that is crucial if we want to understand Brazilian 19th-century society. So that’s why the law has been so important. It’s the sources, the documents that we can find, but it’s not just the documents; it’s the fact that legal decisions have a very big impact on people’s lives and especially the lives of indigenous and Afro-Brazilian groups. So that connection is, I think it’s important. And in many ways they are different from the ones in the U.S. So that’s why we wanted to get this discussion in its own terms. That’s why getting out of the comparative framework was so important. But also, because, as I was saying, there is a meditation about history and the historical process. You know, when you look at the law, when you choose to look at the law, you can see spaces for humans to behave in ways that are unpredictable. Of course, we can see how, but they are kind of unpredictable. And I think this is fascinating, because it doesn’t put us, like, in a box, you know, so it’s for us, look at the subjects in the past, people in the past, and for us to look at our own roles. Just to get outside of this previously defined box. I think this is crucial

 

Fabiane Popinigis:  I feel really connected to Keyla and Celso’s proposal and the introduction to the dossier, which I think is really great because it offers a big key to the reading; it carefully unpacks the historiographical trajectory of the social history of law and justice within Brazilian scholarship. It explains the methodological turn of the 80s and 90s, in close interchange with international historiography, especially U.S. historians of law and justice, in both labour history and the history of slavery. Internally, this coincided with the post-dictatorship period and new social movements.

My article emerges from a broader research project on nineteenth- century wage lawsuits, examining how gender functioned as a key organising principle of the labour market.

That was new, and then I found some Freedmen and freedwomen demanding first freedom, and then wages in court. It was a serious challenge to slavery, but also the demand to be compensated for its illegality.  By turning to the courts, they seemed to believe, in some way, that the justice system could intervene in their favour – that theirs was a legitimate claim. The one I particularly analyse here involves a woman who was kidnapped and enslaved as a child. She fights to win her freedom precisely at the dawn of abolition in Brazil, and she won, but then she wanted to go further, seeking to secure her livelihood, the wages owed to her for her labour, but also compensation for the years she had been illegally enslaved. And so the question I had to answer was: was there a political claim to this kind of compensation for former slaves? And I did discover that yes, there was. One major spokesperson for this cause was José do Patrocínio, a well-known black abolitionist in Brazil who called for a form of reparation and left behind extensive writings on the subject. He fought so that black workers, deprived of a land reform that could never happen, might at least be granted fair wages, education and citizenship. All this was unfolding in the 1880’s, as part of an alternative republican project that never came to fruition. These questions persist, and they remain strikingly relevant today.

And about our field of investigation, at a moment of a kind of history that’s being written, “silencing” historical actors again, especially enslaved people and women who disappear as agents in the history of capitalism, it’s especially important to bring these subjects back into view and to show how much of a difference they made in politics and economics, as relevant subjects of historical process. So, it’s a good time to put these people back in the scene through the “noisy archives” and show what historians can do with the sources and the methodological approaches we have been developing over the last few decades.

 

Robert Bland: Along those lines, I wonder what scholars of the American Civil War can learn from the recent literature in Brazilian history around race and the law, especially around questions of slavery and emancipation. I’m thinking of Greg Grandin’s recent work, America, Ameríca, and the comparative lens he uses. We don’t want to get too bogged down into those comparative questions, but I wonder, for kind of a kind of ongoing conversation between Brazil and the United States in the 19th century. What do you think scholars can learn from each other?

 

Keila Grinberg: I think, I mean, there are several things. And one of the points that I find really interesting in your question is that “what can the US historiography learn” from those different cases? Because it’s normally the other way around, right? Like, just an assumption. And one of the things that I find very powerful. It’s just to think as Brazil was a society that has received around a million enslaved Africans just in the 19th century, and that created a whole different society. A slave society like the US, like places in the Caribbean. But it’s a slave society that is structured around different hierarchies. And even though the number of Africans was so huge, the number of manumitted persons was also not huge in the sense of its hemispheric co-parts. So, what kind of society is that where the racial classifications and the racial hierarchies had such a huge presence in terms of the understanding of this society? So, one of the things that I find really interesting is the dynamics between different kinds of people and not, I mean, just going beyond the slave enslaved person and freed person also the several difference between what we call a master or someone who own another person. That could be someone that just like one enslaved person to 200. So, all these different situations and dynamics that in so many ways they are geographically different than the historians of the Civil War in the US.

I think this is a very interesting topic. So, if you think about, especially about the connections between the Civil War and race and slavery. You see two societies that were created sort of around the same connections between colonialism and the slave trade. But they became radically different. So that’s I think that’s something that can be understood. And also, because we tried to also get out of the particular analysis that connect slavery with the war. It’s all the ways in which the racial Catholic bodies are central to understanding Brazil, even when, you know, in the other articles, even when we’re dealing with indigenous persons, even when we are then we’re just free person. You know, you don’t go anywhere in terms of understanding society without thinking about race.

And one last thing is that by including one article about indigenous groups, the one about Maranhão by Alexandre Pelegrino. I think we are also doing something that is important for us in scholarship as well, which is highlighting the connections between what we can call the non-whites. So, the connections between the experiences of indigenous groups and Afro-Brazilians are new in historiographical terms and definitely need more exploration. So, we understand people’s struggles and people’s movements to change their conditions.

 

Fabiane Popinigis:

I see it as an opportunity of thinking beyond our own subjects and localities, not only by comparing cases, but by understanding how people and ideas circulated, and how people drew on shared experiences to transform their own realities. In the current political moment, this perspective is especially necessary. It keeps open a space for struggles over rights, allowing us to learn from past struggles and carry them forward toward a utopian horizon.

Robert Bland

Robert D. Bland is an Associate Professor of History at the University of Tennessee, Knoxville, and Associate Editor at the Journal of the Civil War Era. He is also the author of Requiem for Reconstruction: Black Countermemory and the Legacy of the Lowcountry's Lost Political Generation (University of North Carolina Press, 2026).

Interview with Lesley Gordon

Interview with Lesley Gordon

In today’s Muster, associate editor Megan Bever interviews Lesley Gordon about her recent book, Dread Danger: Cowardice and Combat in the American Civil War (Cambridge University Press, 2024). Gordon is the Charles G. Summersell Chair of Southern History at the University of Alabama and the past president of the Society of Civil War Historians.

 

Previewing the September 2026 JCWE

Previewing the September 2026 JCWE

This issue’s research essays, all written by early-career scholars, show how conversations in distinctive subfields can help historians develop new perspectives on the Civil War era. One article is deeply informed by environmental history, one by history of religion, and one by the history of foreign relations and empire. Meanwhile all three show how the Civil War opened new and sometimes unexpected possibilities.

Jeremy A. Nelson’s article, “A Beastly Ceasefire: Wildlife in the Civil War South,” demonstrates that amid the destruction of war, some forms of wildlife flourished. The war years, often depicted as a period of unmitigated ecological disaster, were, in fact, a time of regeneration for many species in the South. Many men who hunted game in Southern communities were away at the front, and soldiers often eschewed game hunting, needing to preserve ammunition for combat and finding it more practical to eat rations, often supplemented by livestock confiscated from surrounding farms. Drawing on a wide range of sources, including local government documentation of bounties paid for fox and wolf scalps, Nelson makes a convincing case that by interrupting hunting practices, the war created conditions in which many species lived and even thrived.

Joshua Waddell turns to the question of why the Episcopal Church came back together so quickly after the war, particularly as other Protestant denominations continued to be divided into Northern and Southern branches. In “‘I, for One, Shall Make No Acknowledgment of Wrong’: Race and Sectional Reconciliation in the Reunion of the Episcopal Church, 1865–1866,” Waddell shows that the answers lie in the Church’s particular path toward disunion and in its largely conciliatory Northern leadership. Northern leaders divided over the extent to which their Southern counterparts should express regret for slavery, for withdrawing from the national organization, or for participating in the Confederacy. Southern representatives at a crucial 1865 conference refused to make concessions, but the Northern leadership proved willing to appease them. Thus the Church reunited on conservative, accommodationist terms, setting the stage for a future in which Black Americans often felt marginalized within the institution and chose to leave. Waddell’s article complements a number of articles on the history of churches and religion published by the Journal of the Civil War Era over the last few years.

Freddie Ping takes up the question of how Americans viewed national expansion in the postwar years, looking especially at the purchase of Alaska. Delving into opposition to US acquisition of Alaska, particularly by members of the US House of Representatives in 1868, Ping emphasizes intertwined concerns about climate, geography, and race. In “‘A System of Foreign Colonies’: Space, Nation, and Empire in the Alaska Purchase,” he demonstrates that many Americans subscribed to a vision of climate and geography that wrongly construed Alaska as frigid and largely uninhabitable, at least by people of European descent, and that they also worried that in adding a territory that was not contiguous with the rest of the country, the United States would take on the undesirable attributes of European empires. Although the House did vote to fund the Alaska purchase, opponents’ concerns remained part of political discourse in the United States, reappearing in later debates about the Dominican Republican, Hawai‘i, Guam, American Samoa, the Philippines, and Puerto Rico. The Alaska question in the 1860s, then, comes squarely into view as in important part of postwar debates about the United States’ geographical limits.

We applaud and seek to encourage early-career scholars’ desires to publish their work. This issue is published as the JCWE hosts a second round of article workshops for junior scholars. In our 2025 workshops, historians convened in small groups on Zoom, each gathering mentored by a senior person in the field. They workshopped their own pieces and discussed what journals look for in articles. In late 2025 and early 2026, we began to see the fruits of those workshops in the form of article submissions. We are excited to be able to run this program again in summer and fall 2026.

Gregory Ablavsky’s review essay draws on recent work in Native American history to suggest characterizing the period from the 1820s through the 1880s as a “long Removal” era. In dialogue with Elliott West’s formulation of a “Greater Reconstruction,” Ablavsky invites us to envision post–Civil War developments that are typically considered new departures (including the Plains “Indian Wars” and the end of treaty-making in 1871) as more consistent with the prewar period than previously thought. With nuanced attention to continuity and change, the article also suggests how, in Native American history as in other areas, the states are often laboratories for policies later adopted by the federal government. Our slate of book reviews reveals the vibrancy of the field as well as the generosity of our many colleagues who agree to review books for the journal, thus helping to ensure that people’s work is read and appreciated. Speaking of the book review section, we’re delighted to announce that book review editor Megan Bever has agreed to stay with the journal for a second three-year term. We love what Megan has done with the book review section, including not just her excellent book selections and editing but also her online video interviews with authors, found on Muster.

This calendar year’s special issues have prevented us, until now, from announcing the addition of a new staff member to the journal, Sheena Carroll. Sheena came on board more than a year ago and is doing double duty as the JCWE’s production manager and communications manager for the Richards Center. We’re excited to be working with her. We also announce our newish graduate assistant, Cameron Sauers, who is a PhD candidate at Penn State and joined us in summer 2025. A belated welcome to Sheena and Cameron!

Kate Masur and Greg Downs

Kate Masur is an associate professor at Northwestern University, specializing in the history of the nineteenth-century United States, focusing on how Americans grappled with questions of race and equality after the abolition of slavery. Greg Downs, who studies U.S. political and cultural history in the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, is a professor of history at University of California--Davis. Together they edited an essay collection on the Civil War titled The World the Civil War Made (North Carolina, 2015), and they currently co-edit The Journal of the Civil War Era.

Finding Rabbit: What One Freedman’s Story Reveals About Scholarly Editing

Finding Rabbit: What One Freedman’s Story Reveals About Scholarly Editing

Archives and special collections have long connected users with the raw materials of our history. Researchers visiting our reading rooms encounter the past one page, photograph, and reel at a time. With collections so important to our cultural heritage, history, and future, we’ve been asking: How can university libraries expand access to these materials, help users understand them, and prepare the next generation of scholars and professionals?

When the University of South Dakota Libraries hired me, part of that vision was to deepen the library’s commitment to archival access while also creating meaningful, hands-on professional development opportunities for humanities students. One powerful way archives and libraries are doing both is through digital scholarly editing.

But what exactly are scholarly editions, and how do they differ from collections in digital libraries?

What Is a Digital Scholarly Edition?

A digital scholarly edition is more than a digital archive or scanned collection. Like digital libraries, scholarly editions provide users with access to large amounts of digitized archival materials. What distinguishes them is editorial interpretation.

Researching the historical context, editors transcribe documents, identify and explain references, and create tools that help users discover and understand relationships across the collection. Through this work, scholarly editions transform historical documents from isolated records into a connected, searchable, and contextualized collection.

 

The Civil War & Reconstruction Governors of Mississippi (CWRGM) scholarly edition — a partnership between Susannah J. Ural at Mississippi State University and myself in the USD University Libraries — offers an excellent example of how this works in practice. CWRGM publishes annotated, searchable editions of correspondence sent to Mississippi’s governors during one of the most transformative periods in American history.

At CWRGM, users can engage with the archive in multiple ways. They can keyword search transcriptions and metadata to quickly sift through thousands of records. At the same time, they can browse documents using the archivist’s folder arrangement, which recreates aspects of the traditional reading room experience.

Blog posts and podcasts introduce users to collection highlights and editorial discoveries, while the educator resources support meaningful use of archival materials in K-12, undergraduate, and graduate classrooms. The project’s open-access structured data supports digital humanities research by making relationships across people, events, and ideas visible at scale.

While these features help users explore and engage with the collection in meaningful ways, focused at the document level, CWRGM’s editors and researchers use annotated subject tags to provide readers with historical interpretation and connection.

 

Subject tags connect users to the people, places, events, and ideas that appear within documents. These annotations allow readers to move beyond simply reading a document toward understanding its broader historical context.

 

At CWRGM, these subject tags appear directly within document transcriptions. When users hover over the hyperlinked tagged terms, they encounter editorial interpretation adding context, explaining who individuals were, what events are referenced, or why a concept matters. 

And with one click, users are taken down the rabbit hole.

Looking for Rabbit

In the spring of 1868, Rabbit received a letter from Mary Shaifer, the young white woman he had grown up alongside and whose family had once enslaved him. Just three years after the end of slavery, he read her letter while inside the “Walls” — the Mississippi State Penitentiary in Jackson where growing numbers of Black men like Rabbit found themselves incarcerated by a state increasingly profiting from their labor through convict leasing.

By signing the letter with her full name, Mary Shaifer provided CWRGM researchers with enough evidence to identify her in the archive. As a white woman in antebellum Mississippi, her family’s names appear in the 1860 U.S. Federal census, unlike the 436,631 enslaved African Americans living in the state.

With that information, her reference to “my poor blind brother” becomes Henry Frazer Shaifer, Jr. Hovering over the linked terminology, “blind,” adds additional historical context about blindness in the nineteenth century, including how it was understood and treated for interested readers. Selecting Mary’s description of Rabbit as different “from any other of your color” connects researchers with information about African American history and identity during the Civil War Era, while also discovering every document in the collection about African Americans.

But who was Rabbit?

Even though the link to Rabbit led users to a document written by Mary’s mother, Clarrissa, and another even authored by Rabbit himself, his name remained a mystery. Still, these now-connected letters uncover much about his life.

Following the subject tag for Rabbit reveals a remarkable trail of documents identifying him as a freedman incarcerated in the Mississippi State Penitentiary who sought release by appealing to his former enslavers as a person and the governor as an American citizen. These letters provide insights into the complex nature and network of antebellum and postwar interracial relationships and how swiftly freed people adopted citizenship.

Encountering Rabbit

But if you’re a person who is reading an Archives & Special Collections blog because you like to cross your t’s and dot your i’s and sometimes your lowercase j’s, and you’re worried you won’t learn Rabbit’s name, never fear.

On December 8, 1867, a heartfelt collection of letters accompanied a petition to the Circuit Court of Claiborne County seeking clemency in Rabbit’s case. Among the petition is a letter to his former enslaver pleading for information and assistance, signed “truly “Rabbitt” Harrison Turner.”

Through this editorial work, CWRGM users can uncover Turner’s quest for freedom after emancipation. They will learn that Turner was born enslaved in Mississippi around 1846, he obtained his freedom with abolition in 1865 but became incarcerated, and that after being released, he worked as a laborer in Claiborne County, married Jane Ross, and had two children, Isaiah and Emily. He died in January 1929.

Lindsey R. Peterson

Lindsey R. Peterson, Ph.D. is the Digital Humanities Librarian at the University of South Dakota (Vermillion), co-director of the Civil War & Reconstruction Governors of Mississippi project, and the Managing Director of the Society of Civil War Historians. Peterson has over twelve years of experience teaching U.S. history, developing curriculum, and facilitating continuing education workshops for history teachers.

Announcing the Winner of the 2025 George and Ann Richards Prize

Announcing the Winner of the 2025 George and Ann Richards Prize

Amy Murrell Taylor has won the $1,000 George and Ann Richards Prize for the best article published in The Journal of the Civil War Era in 2025. The article, “More Than a ‘Pile of Rude Boards’: Space, Power, and the Ordeal of a Schoolhouse in the Reconstruction South,” appeared in the June 2025 special issue, War Objects: Material Culture and New Narratives in Nineteenth-Century America, guest edited by Joan E. Cashin and Alaina E. Roberts.

Amy Taylor on October 7, 2025. Photo by Carter Skaggs | UKphoto

The prize committee praised the article as “a bold and powerful contribution to the literature of both material culture and Reconstruction,” stating that Taylor “brilliantly takes the notion of rebuilding after the war and makes it material and almost corporeal.” They further noted, “By showing us how a single building could contain an entire town’s worth of functions… Taylor introduces readers to the tangled web of relationships that shaped Reconstruction on the ground.” The committee called the article “beautifully written” and “replete with evocative imagery that stays with you days after reading.”

Amy Murrell Taylor is the T. Marshall Hahn Jr. Professor of History and a Faculty Affiliate of the Commonwealth Institute for Black Studies at the University of Kentucky. She is the author of Embattled Freedom: Journeys Through the Civil War’s Slave Refugee Camps (UNC Press, 2018), and a co-author, with Daina Ramey Berry, Joseph Crespino, and David Shi, of America: A Narrative History, 13th ed. (W.W. Norton, 2025). Taylor is currently serving as President of the Society for Civil War Historians in 2026-2028.

Awarded annually, the Richards Prize celebrates the generosity of George and Ann Richards, who were instrumental in the growth of the Richards Civil War Era Center and in the founding of The Journal of the Civil War Era. The journal is grateful for the service of this year’s prize committee: Anne Sarah Rubin, University of Maryland, Baltimore County (chair); Elaine Frantz, Kent State University; and Antwain Hunter, The University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill.

 

Robert Bland

Robert D. Bland is an Associate Professor of History at the University of Tennessee, Knoxville, and Associate Editor at the Journal of the Civil War Era. He is also the author of Requiem for Reconstruction: Black Countermemory and the Legacy of the Lowcountry's Lost Political Generation (University of North Carolina Press, 2026).

JCWE Conversation with Maria Angela Diaz

JCWE Conversation with Maria Angela Diaz

In today’s Muster, JCWE Book Review Editor talks with Angela Diaz about her book, Continuous State of War: Empire Building and Race Making in the Civil War-Era Gulf South, which was published by UGA Press in 2024.

 

The Unspendable Pension of Henrietta Emory Meads

The Unspendable Pension of Henrietta Emory Meads

Sometime in July 1867, Henrietta Emory wrote to a clerk in the Claim Division of the Maryland Freedmen’s Bureau describing the challenges she had faced in trying to get money due to her as a soldier’s widow. “I have had so much trouble & gone so in debt to get my poor husband’s bounty, that I was able to do no more,” she lamented. With a young child to support, Henrietta certainly needed the money, which would have amounted to several hundred dollars the U.S. government owed to her deceased husband. She also had good reason to be weary of the process of claiming it, however. Having failed in an earlier bid to claim the benefits that was stymied by a corrupt Freedmen’s Bureau agent, J.P. Creager, Henrietta knew better than anyone that winning access to her rights as a war widow was an expensive endeavor. Her success, she had learned, also relied on the design and operation of a federal bureaucracy that consistently treated Black Southerners—and especially Black women—with suspicion. Nonetheless, she asserted, her claim was sound. “I can prove by the best authority, that I was lawfully married to James Emory,” she insisted. “I was married to him by a Methodist preacher, colored, & my husband paid him for marrying us, he was a regular preacher in the conference, & it was the way all the people were married.” Legally married, she insisted, the hundreds of dollars the government had yet to pay her husband ought to be hers.

I encountered Henrietta’s case in my role as an editor at the Freedmen and Southern Society Project (FSSP) while gathering materials for a forthcoming digital “microedition” on the experiences of Black Marylanders during the Civil War. As I sifted through Henrietta’s numerous petitions to representatives of the Claim Division, I was struck by the forceful manner in which she demanded recognition of her rights as a war widow and by her repeated assertions that the process of  securing  those rights was expensive and unjust. She repeatedly described herself as “a poor woman” who “can not get any thing done with out paying for it and… [was] not able to stand to it.” After identifying additional materials at the National Archives pertaining to Henrietta’s case over the course of transcribing and annotating the materials already in our collection, the reasons for her frustration became clear. In order to secure her rights, Henrietta had to contend with agents of the Freedmen’s Bureau who were frequently corrupt or racist, or both, enduring a process that seemed designed to disqualify Black women living in poverty as she did, all to obtain rights that were ostensibly already hers as a war widow. As we know from recent scholarship, her experiences were all too common among Black women trying to secure the money due them as the widows of Civil War soldiers. These experiences raise important questions about the design of the postwar state, even during the short existence of the Freedmen’s Bureau that historians have tended to see as taking a proactive role in establishing Black rights in the postwar South. Henrietta’s story offers a radically different account of the relationship between the state and the equal rights it allegedly established.

Emory Final Transcription 

 

If it were as simple as establishing the legality of her marriage to the late James Emory in 1860, Henrietta’s case would have been relatively straightforward, even without the documentary, legal, and social resources from which white claimants benefitted. “I have no money nor cant get any to go to Baltimore,” she explained in July 1867, “but I will send a certificate of my marriage, with the preacher’s name to it, sworn to before the county magistrate  I would think this proof enough.” Yet it was not proof enough because, as Brandi Brimmer’s Claiming Union Widowhood methodically demonstrates, the postemancipation state was invested in enforcing white liberal social and sexual norms on Black women rather than simply distributing the benefits to which they were legally entitled. As her case dragged on, Emory seemed increasingly frustrated by the unwillingness of Freedmen’s Bureau officials to treat her marriage as legitimate. “I was Jim Emory’s lawful wife, & have proved it to you, & me & his son Moses, are the lawful ones to have [his unpaid bounty and wages],” she wrote in April 1870. “I have gone to much expense to get it, & am not able to do more for I am a poor woman.” Before her case was closed, Henrietta would have to endure many such humiliating inquiries into the nature of her sexual history. And at each step along the way, she told agents that the process was physically, financially, and emotionally draining. It wasn’t meant to award benefits, she suggested, but to keep the wrong kind of women from accessing their rights.

An image of the affidavit of John Smith, the Black clergyman who married Henrietta and James Emory.

Consisting of thirty-nine pages spread across two separate applications, the documents in our collection pertaining to Henrietta’s case provide an exceptionally rich record of one woman’s struggle to secure her rights and her livelihood in postwar Maryland. At the same time, however, the many gaps and silences in her case both demonstrate the challenges of using the holdings of the National Archives to tell stories such as Henrietta’s and raise important questions about the design and operation of the postwar administrative state and whether it was intended to serve women like her.

Emory Image Sequence Final

 

One problem with the case files generated by Henrietta’s claims is that they provide only a partial window into her struggle—the records are preserved in ways that omit the demands and expectations of the agents who stood between her and the rights she claimed as a war widow. A May 8, 1871 letter accusing Henrietta of promiscuity, for instance, was not included in the Claim Division’s file pertaining to her case. I uncovered it only after additional searches of the division’s press copies of letters-sent volumes. The structure of these records make it all too easy for a researcher to miss this letter and therefore miss a crucial part of the story, one that gives a fuller picture of the racial and sexual priorities and anxieties of the postwar state. The additional communications from the claims office also provide crucial clues as to Henrietta’s relationships. The May 8th letter that finally convinced Henrietta to risk the expensive trip to Baltimore, for example, alleged that she had lived with several different men during her husband’s deployment before marrying another, John Meads. The gravity of these charges and their potentially fatal impact on her claim help explain the urgency of her reply, her sudden willingness to make a difficult and expensive trip to the claims office in Baltimore, and her switch from her previously frustrated and assertive tone to a more subservient one. Henrietta must have seen her rights evaporating into the disdain of the agents tasked with evaluating her claim.

We can also learn a great deal about the community in which Henrietta lived by paying careful attention to her claims and the ways she crafted each communication in response to what she apparently saw as an imposition on rather than a manifestation of her rights. At first glance, for example, it appears that Henrietta wrote the many petitions herself, each composed in the same handwriting in her voice. A short note towards the conclusion of her case, however, reveals that even before she sought out others to petition on her behalf, she worked with someone in her community to navigate the difficult application process. In response to inflammatory allegations of sexual promiscuity contained in the May 8th letter mentioned above, Henrietta replied on May 11th, “I have heard the letter red that you sent to me but it give me very pore incurgement but I will try to Come over [to the claims office in Baltimore] on monday the 21 if I can.” This short note positions Henrietta in quite a different light, dependent upon those around her for assistance—hearing the agent’s letter read to her—rather than providing evidence and making demands for herself as a struggling but self-reliant war widow. The census records reveal that Henrietta was indeed unable to read or write and had evidently had substantial help staking her claim to the benefits her husband had earned in uniform. In light of her May 11th reply, the omission of any mention of assistance from her earlier letters gives a sense of the expectations Henrietta sought to meet in her previous communications, expectations of literacy and respectability that had quickly unraveled amid the allegations of promiscuity.

If the May 8th letter helps us better understand Henrietta’s interaction with the postemancipation state, it also reveals a great deal about the narrow view of rights and benefits advanced by its agents. In previous communications, claims agent Edward C. Knower had instructed Henrietta that she needed only “two witnesses, colored or white, men o[r] women” to demonstrate “that you lived together as man and wife for several years.” “Unless you attend to this matter,” he had warned her, “you will never get your claim settled.” After the allegations of promiscuity came to light, however, Knower tightened the requirements on Henrietta, demanding that she “furnish the testimony of two or more reliable white persons” to satisfy him that the charges against her were baseless. Black testimony would no longer suffice. Harkening back to the prohibitions on Black testimony under the slave state, this shifting requirement reveals not only the narrow, paternalist manner in which postemancipation rights were administered, but also the general suspicion of Black communities as inherently immoral and incapable of fully exercising the rights of citizenship, among which the right to give testimony was one of the most important. Despite all that Black communities had won, and at such a steep cost—as James’s silence in this account attests—the logic of Dred Scott still seemed to animate elements of the postemancipation state.

We don’t know who helped Henrietta petition for her benefits following the initial mishandling of her claim in 1866 by Creager, but her enlistment of further assistance towards the end of the process only added to the inflammatory charges of immorality. When her claim appeared to stall in 1871, she turned to a white acquaintance, merchant John L. Turner, who wrote to Knower on Henrietta’s behalf, asking how to advance the application. After Knower informed him of the allegations of infidelity against Henrietta made by James’s father Samuel, Turner replied that “Henrietta Meeds was in my Store this morning to see Me about the Matter, and I took her to herself and Questioned her, and I she could not offer any evidence against the Statements that Samuel Emery had already Made.” Not only did Turner seize the opportunity “to do any thing that is wright for Sam,” but added to the allegations: “Hennie lived with me also James Emery her husband at the time he went in the army.” The 1870 census listed Henrietta as a cook, and perhaps this was what Turner meant in noting that Henrietta had lived both with him and James, but the context of the statement—Henrietta’s infidelity—suggests otherwise. Maybe Henrietta had already intuited Knower’s demand that she provide statements from “reliable white persons” when she sought aid from Turner, or perhaps Knower had already made these instructions clear. Whatever the case, Henrietta found in Turner’s “assistance” not only a betrayal of the respectable identity she had carefully constructed as Henrietta Emory, but also additional allegations of immorality.

Henrietta and James Emory evidently separated sometime in 1864 after a difficult and apparently abusive union, one doubtless shaped by the trauma of living under a slave state. As well as accusations of sexual immorality, Henrietta’s claim ran up against allegations that she had abused her husband James while they were together. The statement Henrietta provided from James’s physician, L.H. Beatty, asserted for example that “I have no knowledge of his ever being scalded by his wife, as I understand has been represented.” Disproving allegations of abuse was just as important to Henrietta’s application as refuting charges of infidelity. James’s father Samuel, for instance, alleged in his affidavit, quoted in the May 8th letter, not only that “Henrietta lived with other men while James Emory was in the Army,” but “that she was so living when James Emory came home sick on a furlough and she positively refused to receive said Soldier, and Care for him.” Instead, Samuel asserted, she “forced him to leave her and go to his fathers house & during four week [illness?] Henrietta paid no attention to James & did not see him until his burial.” Henrietta did pay her respects to her first husband, but apparently couldn’t bring herself to share a residence or care for him during his sick leave.

If her marriage to Emory was traumatic and painful, her union with John Meads appears to have been more harmonious. The 1880 census records them as still living together, having welcomed nine children into their family during the thirteen years of their marriage. One of the children, Moses, may have been the child she attributed to James in her letters to the Claim Division. By this time, Henrietta was no longer working outside the home as a cook, work that could carry demeaning connotations as well as the daily risk of sexual violence and may well have contributed to Turner’s suggestion of infidelity. While the state had not dignified her first marriage or her rights as a war widow, her second one, at least, seemed to have the quiet dignity and stability she had presented for herself all along.

 

Further Reading

Brandi Brimmer, Claiming Union Widowhood: Race, Respectability, and Poverty in the Post-Emancipation South

Thavolia Glymph, Out of the House of Bondage: The Transformation of the Plantation Household

Tera Hunter, Bound in Wedlock: Slave and Free Black Marriage in the Nineteenth Century

Dale Kretz, Administering Freedom: The State of Emancipation After the Freedmen’s Bureau

 

William Horne

William Horne is a historian of white supremacy and Black liberation movements in the United States. His recent scholarly publications include “White Supremacy and Fraud: The ‘Abolitionist’ Work of Henry Frisbie,” Civil War History 70 no. 3, (September 2024): 69-86; “Abaline Miller and the Struggle for Justice against the Employer Police State after Slavery,” in The Civil War Era and the Summer of 2020, Andy Slap and Hilary Green, eds. (New York: Fordham University Press, 2024), 38-46; “Necessary Utopias: Black Agitation and Human Survival,” Green Theory & Praxis 16 no. 1 (February 2024): 14-33; and “Towards an Unpatriotic Education: Du Bois, Woodson, and the Threat of Nationalist Mythologies,” Journal of Academic Freedom 13 (2022): 1-16. His current book project, “Carnivals of Violence,” examines the systems of white supremacy enshrined in state institutions after emancipation. Horne was co-founder and longtime editor of The Activist History Review and has spoken and published extensively in public-facing venues including TIME, Truthout, The Nation, The Daily Beast, The Washington Post, and the Bucks County Beacon.

Remembering Reconstruction’s Lost Generation

Remembering Reconstruction’s Lost Generation

Benjamin Franklin Randolph was part of a generation that changed the nation’s political history. Born free and raised in Ohio, he attended Oberlin College and after graduating he served as a principal of a Black public school in Buffalo New York. Like many Black northerners of his generation, he saw the Civil War as a pivotal moment in the race’s larger destiny. In December 1863, Randolph volunteered to serve in the Civil War and joined the 26th United States Colored Infantry Regiment.[1]

 

“The Late Rev. B.F. Randolph of South Carolina,” Harper’s Weekly, October 25, 1868

 

After the war, Randolph remained in South Carolina and joined the most important Black political project of his generation. During Reconstruction, he participated in an 1865 Colored Convention in Charleston, joined the Freedmen’s Bureau, and established weekly newspaper for freedmen. “I am desirous of obtaining a position among the freedmen where my qualifications and experience will admit of the most usefulness,” Randolph plead. “I don’t ask position or money. But I ask a place where I can be most useful to my race.”[2]

Motivated by the promise of the new political epoch, he labored tirelessly alongside a larger cohort of freeborn and recently freed Black Americans to make a new world in the postbellum South. In 1867, he was elected as a delegate to the South Carolina Constitutional Convention of 1868 and played a major role in crafting radically democratic provisions in the document that introduced the first system of public schools in the state’s history and granted the franchise to landless men.[3]

Randolph not only served as a beacon for South Carolina’s movement toward abolition democracy but also became a national leader in the Republican Party. He attended the 1868 Republican National Convention that elected Ulysses S. Grant and was nominated by his peers to be one of the nation’s first African American Presidential Electors. He used his growing celebrity to campaign for Republican candidates across the state of South Carolina, shaping the political project that he saw as central to the larger march toward black America’s new destiny.  On October 15, Randolph was in the midst of that very work, campaigning for the Party of Lincoln and Grant in the state’s increasingly violent upcountry region. The next day, while changing trains to head to another campaign event, he was gunned down in broad daylight by three unmasked white assailants.[4]

My book Requiem for Reconstruction: Black Countermemory and the Legacy of the Lowcountry’s Lost Political Generation explores the world that Randolph and his political cohort built, as well as the later efforts to remember the legacy of their political world in the face of the larger cultural attack upon their political project by proponents of the Lost Cause who were actively rewriting Reconstruction’s history to reflect their own white supremacist vision of the nation. This “Reconstruction generation,” composed of the Black teachers, missionaries, journalists, and politicians travelled to the South to aid in the destruction of slavery and established the region’s first Republican Party. [5]

The production of this countermemory was inextricably connected to the violence and tragedy that befell the Reconstruction generation’s political leaders. Just as white mobs dealt death with caustic abandon and the white southern press offered various levels of euphemistic cover to justify the campaigns of extralegal violence, the Reconstruction generation sought to fully memorialize both major and minor political figures from their era. When Ida B. Welles reflected before an 1889 conference of Black journalists that “no requiem, save the night wind, has been sung over the dead bodies,” she not only captured the depth and texture of the violence that shaped postbellum South but also crystallized the funereal cadence of an emergent countermemory of the larger era.[6]

Benjamin Randolph’s funeral serves as one of the first moments where this eulogistic memory was used to provide a forceful defense of Reconstruction’s larger importance in the Black world. In the immediate aftermath of Benjamin Randolph’s assassination, prominent members of the Lowcountry’s political bloc began to deploy Randolph’s death to reconstitute the bonds of the state’s Republican coalition. “He seemed to fully comprehend the fact that our State had been very much broken, the fragments scattered, and to gather them up, and properly unite them, master workmen were required,” lamented northern-born Jonathan Wright. “In every sense of the word, he was a master workman.”[7]

Wright hoped that the Randolph’s legacy would “be felt by generations yet unborn,” a sentiment echoed by many of his Republican colleagues in the legislature. Stephen Swails, a free-born Black New Yorker who had met Randolph in 1864 when both men were stationed in the Lowcountry with different USCT regiments, commented “Senator Randolph is dead, but he still lives in the memories of the Senators who are now here, and his memory will be ever cherished in the hearts of the people of this State.” Another northern-born Republican politician remarked “it is our duty to erect a monument to his memory, not only to mark his resting place, but to commemorate the cause for which he lived and for which he so nobly laid down his life.” Free-born Charlestonian Charles D. Hayne called for a memoriam page in the upcoming issue of the Journal of the House of Representatives of the State of South Carolina.[8]

 

Memorial insert for Benjamin Randolph in December issue of the Journal of the House of Representatives of the General Assembly of South Carolina

 

More than a local or regional story, the effort to produce a Black countermemory of Reconstruction was part of a larger project of Black sectional reconciliation. A wave of new Black newspapers purporting to be truly national in scope and scale, covered the events in the South with close scrutiny. Black journalists forged relationships with Reconstruction-era politicians and traded information to provide the paper’s growing readership with up-to-date political news. Leading editors opined on the actions and events in the South with concern—and at times consternation. In response, a new wave of southern-based Black newspapers emerged in the century’s penultimate decade to confront both the false myths propagated by the white southern press and challenge the whiggish narratives put forth by northern Black leaders about the perceived failures of Black southerners in acquiescing to the New South political order and abandoning Reconstruction.[9]

A.M.E. Metropolitan Church, Washington, D.C., Library of Congress, 1900

 

Nowhere did this new national Black public sphere collide with the production of Black history more than in the Bethel Literary and Historical Society. Founded in 1881, the Bethel Literary was hosted in an auxiliary hall of Washington’s Metropolitan African Methodist Episcopal Church. At once a lyceum and cultural hub of Black Washington’s nascent talented tenth, the Bethel Literary was one of the central nodes in the larger national Black public sphere that connected Black communities across the nascent national network of Black newspapers. “Every Washington correspondent of the Colored press, and there were more then than now, gave conspicuous notice to this institution, and the editors of their home papers often continued the discussion,” observed the Bethel Literary Society’s historian.[10]

The Bethel Literary not only held regular discussions about the history of Reconstruction but also played a major role in marking the passage of the Reconstruction generation. In 1895, the Metropolitan A.M.E. church hosted the funeral of Frederick Douglass. Before the century’s end, John Mercer Langston and Blanche K. Bruce would also receive the equivalent of state funerals at this citadel of Reconstruction-era memory. Following Langston’s funeral, the Washington Bee’s famed editor W. Calvin Chase reflected on the larger epoch-defining meaning of the triumvirate’s passing. “Their wisdom, patriotism, statesmanship, their race love may not be fully appreciated by the present generation,” remarked Chase. “But the men of the future will look in amazement and wonder that these men could have been so brave, so true, so constant amid such adverse conditions.”[11]

In this way, the Reconstruction’s generation’s countermemory was especially sensitive to the moments when major figures passed away. By the twentieth century’s second decade, the rapidly dwindling number of remaining Reconstruction-era leaders was a point of genuine concern for the stewards of Black history in the national press. In 1917, The National Association for the Advancement of Colored People’s national magazine, The Crisis, published a piece reflecting on the passing of the previous political generation. Of the three figures profiled in the photograph, only P.B.S. Pinchback was still alive. Three years later during an effort to capture oral histories and collect archival material from the Reconstruction era, one interviewee lamented “I have long felt that the last opportunity to collect data concerning this interesting period is while this present generation lives. The next generation will have no interest in it.”[12]

 

“Shadows of Light,” The Crisis, August 1917

 

In many ways, Chisholm captured her era’s deep cultural turmoil over the legacy of Reconstruction. Woodrow Wilson had recently ousted a generation of Black officeholders from the federal government, the Republican Party had been made essentially moribund in the South by formal disfranchisement measures, D.W. Griffith’s 1915 film Birth of a Nation exploded as a sensation in American popular culture, reflecting a broader embrace of Confederate memory in the national consciousness.[13]

And yet, Black countermemory persisted during the nation’s Jim Crow years. In Columbia, South Carolina, Randolph Cemetery, which had been established in 1872 to commemorate the legacy of Benjamin Randolph would serve as the final resting place for many of the era’s Black political leaders.

 

“Randolph Cemetery,” National Park Service, June 23, 2022

 

Far from forgetting the story, local communities and national institutions sought to preserve the story of Reconstruction, building the intellectual and cultural scaffolding for a new historical vision that would not only challenge the myth of the Lost Cause but also provide a blueprint for the Second Reconstruction—the American Civil Rights Movement. Blood soaked and hard won, the story the Reconstruction generation and their descendants crafted offers a deep and textured portrait of what it means to think deeply about the past. It is a story worth remembering.

 

[1] “Rikers Island-Trained USCT Regiments’ Chaplains,” New York Correction History Society, www.Correctionhistory.org/html/chronicl/cw-usct/2rikersusctchaplains.html

[2] “Rikers Island-Trained USCT Regiments’ Chaplains.”

[3] Alrutheus Ambush Taylor, Negro in South Carolina, 383; Thomas C. Holt, Black over White: Negro Political Leadership in South Carolina during Reconstruction (Urbana: University of Illinois Press, 1977), 131-34; W. E. B. Du Bois, Black Reconstruction in America, 1860-1880 (New York: Harcourt, Brace and Company, 1935), chap. 7.

[4] Zuczek, State of Rebellion: Reconstruction in South Carolina (Columbia: University of South Carolina Press, 1996), 54-57, 60.

[5] Robert D. Bland, Requiem for Reconstruction: Black Countermemory and the Legacy of the Lowcountry’s Lost Political Generation (Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press, 2026). On the use of generation in African American history, see Ira Berlin, Many Thousands Gone: The First Two Centuries of Slavery in North America (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1998); Sarah L.H. Gronningsater, Rising Generation: Gradual Abolition, Black Legal Culture, and the Making of National Freedom (Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press, 2024); Andrew B. Lewis, Shadows of Youth: The Remarkable Journey of the Civil Rights  Generation (New York: Farrar, Straus, and Giroux, 2009).

[6] Irvine Garland Penn, The Afro-American Press and Its Editors (Springfield, MA: Wiley and Company, 1891), 186. On the broader cultural history of funereal thinking in Black life, see LeRhonda Manigault Bryant, Talking to the Dead: Religion, Music, and Lived Memory among Gullah/Geechee Women (Durham: Duke University Press, 2014); David Roediger, “And Die in Dixie: Funerals, Death, and Heaven in the Slave Community, 1700-1865,” The Massachusetts Review 22 (Spring 1981): 163-183; Christina Sharpe, In the Wake: On Blackness and Being (Durham: Duke University Press, 2014).

[7] Journal of the House of Representatives of the State of South Carolina, 14.

[8] Journal of the House of Representatives of the State of South Carolina, 15-16, 44-45.

[9] On the postbellum Black press and public sphere, see Elsa Barkley Brown, “Negotiating and Transforming the Public Sphere: African American Political Life in the Transition from Slavery to Freedom,” Public Culture 7 (Fall 1994): 107-46; Penn, Afro-American Press; Benjamin Fagan, Frederick Douglass’s Newspapers: Black Organizing and the Press for Freedom (Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press, 2026); Eric Gardner, Black Print Unbound: The Christian Recorder, African American Literature, and Periodical Culture (New York: Oxford University Press, 2015); Henry Lewis Suggs, ed. The Black Press in the South, 1865-1979 (Westport, Conn.: Greenwood Press, 1983).

[10] John W. Cromwell, History of the Bethel Literary and Historical Association, 15-17, 21-22

[11] “Hon. B.K. Bruce Dead,” Colored American (Washington, DC), March 19, 1898; “Death of the Triumvirate,” Washington Bee, March 26, 1898.

[12] “Shadows of Light,” The Crisis, August 1917, 181; Helen James Chisolm to Monroe Work, February 14, 1920, in Scurlock et al., “Additional Information and Correction,” Journal of Negro History 5 (April 1920): 248.

[13] Eric S. Yellin, Racism in the Nation’s Service: Government Workers and the Color Line in Woodrow Wilson’s America (Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press, 2016). On the production of Lost Cause memory during the early twentieth century, see David W. Blight, Race and Reunion: The Civil War in American Memory (Cambridge, MA: Belknap Press of Harvard University Press, 2001), 394-97; Karen L. Cox, Dixie’s Daughters: The United Daughters of the Confederacy and the Preservation of Confederate Culture (Gainesville: University of Florida Press, 2003); Paul McEwan, The Birth of a Nation (British Film Institute, 2015).

Robert Bland

Robert D. Bland is an Associate Professor of History at the University of Tennessee, Knoxville, and Associate Editor at the Journal of the Civil War Era. He is also the author of Requiem for Reconstruction: Black Countermemory and the Legacy of the Lowcountry's Lost Political Generation (University of North Carolina Press, 2026).